Bears vs. Colts Predictions, Picks & Odds: NFL Week 3, Sunday 9/22

It’s been a while since we’ve seen this one, but the Week 3 NFL slate does indeed feature a Super Bowl rematch. Back in 2007, the Indianapolis Colts took down the Chicago Bears for QB Peyton Manning’s first Lombardi Trophy, and the two teams will match up again this Sunday. It may not be for all the marbles, but we still have our best Bears vs. Colts predictions.
You can decide if you’d like to fade or follow the best bet from our Bears vs. Colts picks, but you’ll be able to do so with a guaranteed $200+ FanDuel Sportsbook sign up bonus that we also have for you!
Bears vs. Colts Predictions for NFL Week 3, Sunday 9/22
As much as we’d love to reference a past Super Bowl, that game obviously doesn’t have anything to do with Bears vs. Colts predictions for this weekend. Well, we did mention Manning, and Chicago features another heavily touted rookie QB in Caleb Williams.
His NFL career has had a shaky start for sure, and this Sunday, he’ll be the counterpart to a #3 overall pick two drafts ago with Indy QB Anthony Richardson. These two young gunslingers could certainly lead the next generation of QBs, having us look back at this matchup years from now.
We’ll have to wait and see, but for now, we have two teams that have a combined one win so far this season.
Chicago Bears: Continuing To Develop Caleb
As has been the case since the 2024 NFL Draft, the primary storyline surrounding Chicago is former USC QB Caleb Williams. He’s considered to be the next best thing at the position but hasn’t looked like that just yet.
It certainly hasn’t been poor enough for it to be panic time in the Windy City, but it is still the number one thing every fan is monitoring. Thus far, we’ve seen him bailed out by his defense and special teams in Week 1, while Week 2 was a loss on Sunday Night Football to a QB that had a record setting rookie season - Houston Texans C.J. Stroud.
Indianapolis Colts: Dialing Up The Discipline
While there may be some Williams woes in Chicago, those are normal rookie growing pains. On the flip side, the Colts still have yet to get their first win of the season. However, we’re also not implying Richardson is the sole reason for that.
In Week 1, he led the team in rushing while tossing two touchdown passes, but the aforementioned Stroud simply outscored them. In Week 2, Indy had star RB Jonathan Taylor break 100 yards rushing, but it was untimely penalties and turnovers that cost them the game despite allowing just 16 points.
That lack of discipline isn’t going to fly with how well the Texans look to be playing, but will they clean things up for Week 3?
Bears vs. Colts Odds, Spreads, Total & Betting Lines
Before we help answer that question with the best bet from our Bears vs. Colts picks, here are the latest Bears vs. Colts odds at FanDuel Sportsbook:
- Point Spread: Chicago Bears +1.5 (-115) vs. Indianapolis Colts -1.5 (-105)
- Money Line: Chicago Bears (+104) vs. Indianapolis Colts (-122)
- Game Total (Over/Under): Over 43.5 (-112) vs. Under 43.5 (-108)
Bears vs. Colts Predictions: Under 43.5 Points (-108 at FanDuel Sportsbook)
After everything that we’ve gone through thus far, you may have been surprised to see that the Bears vs. Colts odds have Indy as the favorites. Of course, it’s still a tight point spread, so we’re going to focus our Bears vs. Colts predictions elsewhere.
However, our best bet is still targeting what may end up being one of the biggest line movements of the entire season! After opening at 47 points, the total has plummeted to just 43.5 points. Even with that being the case, we still don’t feel as though it has been adjusted enough.
We’re expecting whichever team that gets to 20 points to win this game, which will be a struggle for them both based on what we’ve seen so far. Admittedly, you’ll see that Indy put up 27 points in Week 1, but that was more a product of Houston’s defensive lapses. That was proven last Sunday with the Colts scoring just 10 points against a porous Green Bay Packers defense that allowed 34 points in Week 1.
The Bears were in a similar scenario on the opening Sunday. While they won their matchup with the Tennessee Titans 24-17, the offense scored just three field goals for nine points. It was a punt block returned for a touchdown and a pick six of Titans QB Will Levis that won them that game.
Then, on SNF this past Sunday, that same Texans defense that gave up 27 to the Colts held Chicago to just 13 points. All that adds up to this - both teams have struggled to eclipse the 20-point barrier.
Therefore, the best bet from our Bears vs. Colts predictions is under 43.5 points (-108 at FanDuel Sportsbook).
Bears vs. Colts Injury Report & Latest News
Make sure to check out the latest injury news following Thursday’s practice report before locking in any Bears vs. Colts picks:
IND Colts:
- DE Laiatu Latu - DNP
GB Packers:
- WR Keenan Allen
- FB Khari Blasingame - DNP
- OL Teven Jenkins - Limited
- DL Zacch Pickens - DNP
- TE Mercedes Lewis - DNP
- DL Andrew Billings - Limited
- OL Nate Davis - Limited
- RB Travis Homer - Limited
- WR Rome Odunze - Limited
- DL Montez Sweat - Limited
- DL DeMarcus Walker - Limited
How To Bet On Bears vs. Colts At FanDuel Sportsbook & Claim Your $200+ Bonus
We promised a guaranteed $200+ FanDuel sign up bonus to go along with our Bears vs. Colts predictions, and it’s now time to share that with you! It’s perfect for the NFL season as well, and you won’t even need a FanDuel promo code when you become a new member through us. Then, just deposit $10 or more.
All that is left to do is wager $5 or more on anything, even if it’s not our Bears vs. Colts predictions. It doesn’t even have to win, and FD will boost your account with $200 in bonus bets! Add to that three free weeks of NFL Sunday Ticket, and this FanDuel promo is as good as it gets. So, why not create a new account today?
Player News
Dolphins signed No. 13 overall pick DT Kenneth Grant to a four-year contract.
ESPN’s Jeremy Fowler reports that Grant will sign his contract today. The former Michigan defensive tackle is expected to fill a major void left by Christian Wilkins, who left for the Raiders in the 2024 offseason. Grant totaled 32 tackles, three sacks, and seven TFLs in his final season at Michigan and excelled at stopping the run while also generating 27 pressures in his final season, per PFF.
Beat reporter John Hendrix reports that free agent WR Donovan Peoples-Jones is among the 16 players that the Saints will host for their rookie minicamp.
Peoples-Jones last played regular season snaps with the Lions back in 2023, when he caught 13-of-24 targets for 155 yards. He is highly unlikely to return to fantasy relevance at this point but could perhaps sign on as a special teams contributor.
Titans signed fourth-round pick WR Elic Ayomanor to a four-year contract.
Ayomanor will now begin learning behind Calvin Ridley. Although Ayomanor is unlikely to find a meaningful role in year one, dynasty managers should note his status as training camp gets underway this summer. The former Stanford receiver flashed big-play ability in his two college seasons.
Buccaneers signed seventh-round pick WR Tez Johnson to a four-year contract.
Johnson will serve as a rotational deep-threat option for Baker Mayfield. His thin frame (5'10/154) simply does not lend itself to the repeated hits one incurs in a full-time role. Johnson did earn 100-plus targets in his two seasons at Oregon, though. His big-play style make him a better fit in best ball for now, pending any major on-field breakthroughs.
Giants waived DT Casey Rogers.
Rogers was a 2024 undrafted free agent and logged 33 defensive snaps for the Giants in his rookie season. He is credited with zero tackles and/or sacks. He may find his way onto another roster as a practice squad option.
Vikings signed third-round pick WR Tai Felton to a four-year contract.
Felton is quietly in play to challenge Vikings No. 3 WR Jalen Nailor in training camp. Nailor (5'11/190) caught 28-of-42 targets for 414 yards and six touchdowns in his first season as a starter last year, with the latter category buoying his fantasy productivity. Felton (6'1/183), meanwhile, caught 96-of-143 targets for 1,119 yards and nine touchdowns while averaging 2.32 yards per route run in his final college season. Fantasy managers should monitor Felton’s training camp reports this summer, as he could have a matchup-based WR5 role if everything falls into place.