NFL Week 16 Best Bets and Player Props

While I don't have any game picks against the spread for the NFL Week 16 Saturday games, I wanted to get this piece out early to give you enough time to make your football betting decisions before they start. If you caught Friday's Bettor Sports Betting Show, you'll see that Dan Servodidio has a couple of game picks for today and, actually, I have a couple of player props for Saturday as well. We got our best bets off to a solid start for the week with the Thursday night game and we're ready to keep that momentum going with picks, not just for Saturday and Sunday, but for the three-game Christmas Day slate as well. So buckle up and let's get to it!
NFL Week 16 Best Bets
Indianapolis Colts at Atlanta Falcons
I mean, who trusts Arthur Smith or the Falcons at this point? Seriously, who? Not only are the Falcons 4-10 ATS this season, but now Smith is trying to save his job by throwing his quarterback under the bus. The switch to Taylor Heinicke has already failed once, but he's going back to it in an effort to show his boss that he was handicapped from the start because of not having a proper QB. But the decisions have been a travesty all year and even here at the end of the 2023 NFL season, we aren't encouraged regarding a turnaround. Yes, the Colts defense is flawed overall, but they've done a great job of putting pressure on the opposing quarterback and creating turnovers. Unless Smith runs the football 72 times, we could be getting vintage Heinicke who loves to throw the ball to opposing defenders. With the return of both Jonathan Taylor and Michael Pittman, the Colts have the offense to keep this one super-close and even win outright. I was tempted to take the Colts money line, but if the books are going to give me points, I'll take 'em!
Pick: Colts +2.5 (-110)
Jacksonville Jaguars at Tampa Bay Buccaneers
There is just way too much love being thrown around at Baker Mayfield for my liking. Yes, he had a phenomenal game last week and the Jaguars pass defense has been suspect, at best, but this is still Baker Mayfield we're talking about and he can just as easily put up a clunker as he can throw for 300 yards and multiple touchdowns. There's an obvious concern for the Jaguars offense as Trevor Lawrence has yet to be cleared from concussion protocol, but even with C.J. Beathard under center, the Jaguars should be able to expose the vulnerability of the middle of the field for the Bucs shaky pass defense. I'm not going to call this a true road game for the Jaguars, but it's also worth noting Jacksonville is 5-1 both straight up and against the spread on the road this season. I also like betting this game before they announce Lawrence's status. If he plays, I'm guessing this could turn into a pick 'em so take the points while you can.
Pick: Jaguars +2.5
Green Bay Packers at Carolina Panthers
Have you seen the way the Panthers are controlling the ball and the clock ever since Chris Tabor took over as the interim coach? He's given Chuba Hubbard the rock at least 22 times in each of the last three games and Carolina is putting out these long, sustained drives that just chew up the clock. That, coupled with the fact that Aaron Jones is returning to action and will likely get the call often from Matt LaFleur, this game could move pretty quickly and with a low point total. The under is 9-4-1 in Panthers games this season (3-1 over their last four) and that's with a point total below 40. The under may be 6-8 in Packers games this season, but Carolina controls the clock and that will keep the scoring down.
Pick: Under 37.5 (-110)
Las Vegas Raiders at Kansas City Chiefs
People are still telling me the Chiefs struggle to cover big spreads at home and while that was once a very true statement, it doesn't turn out to be the case this season. In fact, in the three home games where the Chiefs have been favored at home by more than 5.5 points, they are 3-0 against the spread and two of those games had double-digit spreads. We just watched the Chiefs wreck the Raiders 31-17 back during Thanksgiving week and they are in need of some big wins here to close out the season and reassert themselves as one of the favorites to win the AFC and Super Bowl. I just don't see the Raiders keeping this one close enough, especially if Josh Jacobs is out.
Pick: Chiefs -10 (-110)
Favorite NFL Week 16 Player Props:
- Tyler Boyd over 3.5 receptions (+100)
- James Cook over 68.5 rushing yards (-115)
- DJ Moore over 64.5 receiving yards (-120)
- Chuba Hubbard over 16.5 rushing attempts (-115)
- DK Metcalf Anytime TD + Seahawks win (+175)
- Gardner Minshew Anytime TD (+450)
**all lines & odds courtesy of BetMGM
Player News
ESPN’s Jeremy Fowler reports Saints hosted free agent CB Asante Samuel for a visit Monday.
Samuel, fresh off offseason neck surgery, visited with the Saints Monday as he pursues his next playing opportunity. He has clear connection to the franchise after they hired Brandon Staley to fill their defensive coordinator position, for whom Samuel played under with the Chargers. Fowler adds that Samuel has another doctor visit scheduled for early July, during which time he hopes to gain clearance to resume football activities.
ESPN’s Adam Schefter reports Packers met with WR Jayden Reed’s agent, Drew Rosenhaus, to clarify his status with the team.
The meeting comes after the Packers selected a wide receiver in the first round for the first time since 2002 in this year’s draft. ESPN’s Adam Schefter added that the team emphasized Reed’s status as the top option at wide receiver after the selection of Matthew Golden and Savion Williams. “Green Bay’s top receiver” means far less for fantasy than it does in other places around the league considering Reed led the team with just 62.6% of the team’s offensive snaps played in 2024.
Saints signed QB Hunter Dekkers.
Dekkers spent three seasons with the Cyclones of Iowa State before stepping away from football following an indictment surrounding charges related to sports gambling. He then played his final collegiate season at Iowa Western before being invited to Saints camp. Dekkers spent his redshirt season backing up Brock Purdy at Iowa State.
Seahawks signed No. 18 overall pick OG Grey Zabel to a four-year contract.
Per ESPN’s Adam Schefter, Zabel’s deal is worth a guaranteed $18.471 million. The former North Dakota State guard will be tasked with bolstering a Seahawks line that ranked 26th in PFF pass blocking grades and 24th in run blocking grades. The Seahawks didn’t do much to address their offensive line this offseason, with Zabel being the biggest addition to date. The FCS stud showed out at this year’s senior bowl, and brings high expectations into his rookie season after dominating at the college ranks.
Free agent WR Gabe Davis is visiting the 49ers on Monday.
It’s the first known interest we’ve seen of Davis, who was released by the Jaguars last week with a failed physical designation. The 49ers will likely be without Brandon Aiyuk to start the season, and the idea of adding another veteran to the room is appealing. Kyle Shanahan can turn a lot of football players into something fantasy-interesting, but Davis might be a step beyond even his schemes.
Falcons released WR Phillip Dorsett.
What was your favorite moment of Dorsett’s three-month run on a reserve/future contract with the Falcons? Was it when the signing was announced, or was it when the release happened? Dorsett will try to bounce to another team as wideout depth as he enters his age-32 season. He did not play NFL snaps last year and was only targeted three times by the Broncos in 2023.