Fantasy Football Week 5 Running Back Handcuff Report: Trey Sermon & More

There are a few reasons that could cause a starting fantasy football RB to lose his job to his RB handcuff but one of the biggest is if he can’t hold onto the football.
Former New England Patriots head coach Bill Belichick is famous for saying that “ball security is job security”. Kansas City Chiefs RB Carson Steele and New England Patriots RB Rhamondre Stevenson know that all too well.
Fantasy Football NFL Week 5 Running Back Handcuff Report
Steele looked like the Chiefs’ primary early down back after his Week 3 performance but after fumbling early in the team’s Week 4 matchup against the Los Angeles Chargers he spent most of the rest of the game riding the bench.
It was the second fumble he’s lost this season, and it opened the door for Kareem Hunt to take over as the Chiefs’ primary back for the rest of the game. It now appears that Hunt should be considered the team’s lead back with Steele operating as his Fantasy Football Week 5 Running Back Handcuff.
According to Kansas City Star sports columnist Scott McDowell, Hunt looked good in Week 4 but revealed that he was limited due to a sports hernia injury last season. He better hold onto that football in Week 5 because Clyde Edwards-Helaire is eligible to return from the IR this week.
As an RB who formerly led the Chiefs’ backfield, he can quickly become the next man up or Fantasy Football Week 5 Running Back Handcuff, and if Hunt should falter Edwards-Helaire could become “the man”.
How To Find The Best RB Handcuffs
New England Patriots RB Rhamondre Stevenson’s job security seems to be on the line after he fumbled for a fourth time in Week 4. Mike Reiss, ESPN NFL Nation Patriots beat writer, suggested that Patriots head coach Jerod Mayo is considering starting Antonio Gibson over Stevenson in Week 5.
Unfortunately for the Pats, Gibson has suffered from the same fumbleitis that’s been plaguing Stevenson, for years. Sometimes the best handcuff is the handcuff of a handcuff.
With Washington Commanders RB Austin Ekeler, who is Brian Robinson’s Fantasy Football Week 5 Running Back Handcuff, inactive due to a concussion, Jeremy McNichols stepped in and scored two touchdowns in a blowout Commanders win. Ekeler should be back in Week 5 but it’s probably wise to keep McNichols on our 2024 Week 5 RB Handcuff Report watch list.
Top 5 RB Handcuffs Ahead Of NFL Week 5
Trey Sermon, Indianapolis Colts
As this article is being written Jonathan Taylor hasn’t officially been listed as out in Week 5 but with his having suffered a mild high ankle sprain in Week 4 there’s a good chance that he won’t play this week.
Sermon, Taylor’s Fantasy Football Week 5 Running Back Handcuff, should slide right in as his replacement as the team’s primary back and if he plays, he’ll have a good matchup against the Jacksonville Jaguars.
Sermon has good underlying skills and at just 25 years old he still has fresh legs. He averaged 6.5 yards per carry (YPC) while playing at Oklahoma and with Ohio State in his college career.
Alexander Mattison, Las Vegas Raiders
Zamir White has been just awful for the Raiders this season. White has yet to score a TD and he’s averaging just 3.1 YPC. Mattison, White’s RB handcuff, led the Raiders backfield in rushing yards (60, 12 YPC) in Week 4 despite only having five carries compared to 17 for White.
White only rushed for 50 yards (2.9 YPC) in Week 5. Raiders head coach Antonio Pierce implied that Mattison would be more involved in the team's offense moving forward.
Antonio Gibson, New England Patriots
As we mentioned earlier Stevenson’s job is on the line and Gibson is his RB handcuff. Familiarize yourself with Jamychal Hasty who is also part of the Patriots’ backfield and technically, he’s Gibson’s Fantasy Football Week 5 Running Back Handcuff.
Gibson has 12 career fumbles, and I doubt the Pats would be as patient with him as they’ve been with Stevenson should his fumbling issues resurface.
Tyler Allgeier, Atlanta Falcons
When discussing the 2024 Week 5 RB Handcuff Report, Allgeier should always be considered one of fantasy football’s most important RB handcuffs, but even more so this week.
Bijan Robinson has been limited due to a hamstring injury he suffered in Week 4. If he’s inactive in Week 5 Allgeier will almost certainly be the Falcons’ starter at the RB position.
He’d have a good matchup against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers who have given up the ninth highest average PPR fantasy points per game to RBs this season. Allgeier has 27 carries so far this season and is averaging a whopping 6.1 YPC.
Tank Bigsby, Jacksonville Jaguars
There is no imminent danger of Travis Etienne losing his job, but the Jaguars did previously mention that they wanted to lighten his load this season. Etienne’s 52% share of the team’s offensive snaps in Week 4 was his lowest of the season.
Bigsby is coming off his best game of the season, having rushed for 90 yards and averaging 12.86 YPC. Both Bigsby and Etienne were limited in practice this week due to shoulder injuries.
Player News
Browns RB Quinshon Judkins was charged with misdemeanor domestic battery in Fort Lauderdale, Florida.
Details around Judkins’ arrest continue to emerge. On Sunday, Sergeant David Soika of the shared that upon arriving at the scene where the reported crime took place, officers determined after speaking to the victim that a battery occurred, which led to the arrest of Judkins soon after. The rookie second-rounder remained in police custody overnight and is scheduled to have an initial hearing on Sunday. As ProFootballTalk’s Mike Florio points out, Judkins is sure to face scrutiny from the NFL under the league’s Personal Conduct Policy, while Florio also notes that “the baseline punishment for a battery is six games,” which can vary based on other factors. Judkins has not yet signed his rookie deal, and will likely take less guaranteed money than he hoped for following his arrest, which could cause a trickle-down effect for the 29 other rookie second-rounders who have yet to sign their deal. Judkins was expected to compete for the Browns’ RB1 spot in training camp, and while he will still get a chance to do so, fantasy managers should remain open to the possibility of a suspension being handed down at some point this season. In any case, Jerome Ford rookie Dylan Sampson would both see slight boosts to their fantasy stocks if Judkins were to miss any time.
Browns RB Quinshon Judkins has been arrested and held on domestic violence charges in Fort Lauderdale, Fla.
Judkins was booked on Saturday and remains in custody as of this evening. ESPN’s Daniel Oyefusi reports Judkins’ initial court appearance will come Sunday morning. The Browns have said they are “aware and gathering more details.” Judkins’ arrest comes on the eve of training camp, and gets his professional career off to the worst possible start. A lengthy stay on the commissioner’s exempt list would be all but guaranteed if the charges stick. A suspension would then follow if he were convicted or admitted guilt. The situation should be updated on Sunday.
NFL Network’s Ian Rapoport reports Chargers second-round WR Tre Harris did not report with fellow rookies.
That effectively makes Harris a holdout, something that has become common practice for second-round players amidst ongoing negotiations regarding guaranteed money. 30 of the 32 second-round selections from the 2025 NFL Draft have yet to sign their rookie contracts, with Harris now the first official holdout after the Chargers’ rookie report date came and went. This appears to be nothing more than “just business,” but fantasy managers will want to track the ongoing behind-the-scenes saga unfolding this year.
Veteran DT Ndamukong Suh announced his retirement from the NFL.
Suh announced his retirement in a heartfelt post on X early Saturday morning, bringing up a conversation he had with his father before the latter’s passing as the deciding factor of his decision. “It’s time to let football go. You’ve done everything you set out to do. Now it’s time for the next chapter,” Suh reflects. The five-time All-Pro amassed 600 combined tackles in 199 games during his 13-year professional career, winning Super Bowl LV as a member of the Buccaneers during the 2021 season. He last played for the Eagles in 2022 before failing to catch on as a free agent the following two seasons.
ESPN’s Daniel Oyefusi reports Kenny Pickett “developed a strong on-field rapport” with Jerry Jeudy after training with the team’s top receiver this offseason.
At 27 years old, Pickett is the middle-aged member of the Browns’ four-person quarterback competition. Although he is perhaps the least discussed member of the bunch, Oyefusi notes, Pickett respectably went “14-10 as a starter in two seasons with the Steelers.” Developing rapport with the team’s top option could give Pickett an edge in training camp and the preseason, though Pickett is unlikely to produce even high-end QB2 results were he to win the starting job.
Browns head coach Kevin Stefanski is expected to return to the scheme he ran early in his Cleveland tenure “with more under-center formations that utilize play-action.”
The Browns employed a 24.9 percent play-action pass play rate last season, ranking 17th among NFL teams. In his first season at the helm in 2020, Stefanski ran play action at a sixth-ranked 28.7 percent rate. Increasing the fantasy-friendly play’s usage would be a boon to Browns pass catchers. They can use all of the schematic advantages they can get, given their team’s unsettled quarterback situation.