Rhys Hoskins Fantasy Baseball 2025: Is He A Sleeper Pick Or Fool's Gold?

Rhys Hoskins has been turning heads this spring training with an impressive display of power at the plate. The Milwaukee Brewers’ first baseman, coming off a year lost to a torn ACL, has been mashing baseballs with the ferocity of a dragon unleashed.
Through his first dozen games in the Cactus League, Hoskins has already launched four home runs, boasting a slugging percentage north of .700. Fantasy baseball managers are salivating at the prospect of a return to his 2018-2019 form with the Philadelphia Phillies, where he averaged 31.5 homers per season.
But as the regular season looms like a dark storm on the horizon, questions linger: can Hoskins maintain this mythical power surge in Milwaukee, or will his bat falter like a knight unarmored?
Rhys Hoskins Stats
Hoskins’ spring stats are undeniably enchanting. His plate discipline remains sharp, with a walk rate hovering around 15%, and his hard-hit rate suggests he’s making solid contact. Yet, spring training is a realm of mirages—small sample sizes and lesser competition can inflate numbers like a wizard’s illusion.
In 2022, his last full season, Hoskins hit 30 homers but saw his batting average dip to .246 and his strikeout rate climb to 26.8-percent. The knee injury that sidelined him for all of 2023 adds another layer of uncertainty. Will his legs hold up under the grind of a 162-game campaign? Power hitters often rely on lower-body strength to drive the ball, and any lingering effects could sap his ability to consistently go deep.
Then there’s the matter of American Family Field, the Brewers’ home, which isn’t quite the hitter’s paradise that Citizens Bank Park was during Hoskins’ prime. Milwaukee’s park-factors tend to suppress home runs slightly compared to Philadelphia, and the cooler early-season weather in Wisconsin might further dampen his output.
Hoskins has historically thrived in warmer months—his career OPS is .885 in July versus .784 in April—so a slow start could test the patience of fantasy owners expecting instant fireworks. Add in the Brewers’ lineup, which lacks the star-studded support he enjoyed with Bryce Harper and company, and Hoskins may face more pressure to carry the load, potentially leading to pressing at the plate.
Rhys Hoskins Fantasy 2025
The fantasy implications are as tangled as a sorcerer’s riddle. Hoskins’ fantasy baseball ADP has been on the rise lately (jumping nearly two rounds over the first three weeks of March), reflecting optimism about his spring resurgence. He’s a tantalizing pick for those seeking late power at first base, a position that grows increasingly thinner each year, it seems.
But the risks loom large. A regression to his 2022 form—solid but not spectacular—seems plausible, and a full collapse isn’t out of the question if his body betrays him. Fantasy managers must weigh whether Hoskins is a phoenix rising or a fading star cloaked in spring’s deceptive glow.
Fantasy Baseball Projections 2025: Rhys Hoskins
In the end, Hoskins’ 2025 season in Milwaukee could go either way—a tale of triumph or a cautionary fable.
For now, his spring training heroics are a siren’s song, luring drafters to his potential. But like any quest, the true test lies ahead, and only time will reveal if his power endures or crumbles like a castle made of sand.
Player News
Tanner Scott blew a save while allowing a run against the Tigers on Friday.
Dillon Dingler homered and tripled in an extra-inning loss to the Dodgers on Friday.
Freddie Freeman hit a two-run homer in an extra-inning win for the Dodgers over the Tigers on Friday.
Beau Brieske blew a save while allowing four runs and recording just one out against the Dodgers on Friday in the 10th inning.
Mookie Betts homered twice including a walk-off three-run homer in the 10th inning Friday to give the Dodgers a win over the Tigers.
Jack Flaherty was charged for two runs in 5 2/3 innings while not factoring into the decision Friday against the Dodgers.