23 years old
Bats/Throws: L/R
Height/Weight: 6’1”, 205 lbs
Position: Starting Pitcher
THE NUMBERS
| LEVEL | W-L | ERA | WHIP | K/9 | BB/9 | IP |
2012 | RK | 0-4 | 3.46 | 1.23 | 10.0 | 4.2 | 26 |
2013 | A | 6-5 | 3.18 | 1.35 | 10.1 | 4.2 | 104.2 |
2014 | High-A | 3-6 | 5.47 | 1.56 | 10.7 | 5.2 | 97 |
2015 | AA | 3-1 | 0.56 | 0.94 | 13.5 | 3.9 | 32 |
2015 | MLB | 6-7 | 3.22 | 1.19 | 9.24 | 3.08 | 125.2 |
2016 | AA, AAA | 0-0 | 1.12 | 0.88 | 12.4 | 2.2 | 8 |
2016 | MLB | 6-5 | 3.22 | 1.54 | 11.78 | 5.00 | 81.0 |
Career |
| 12-12 | 3.22 | 1.33 | 10.23 | 3.83 | 206.2 |
Minor League Overall Rankings per season.
| Baseball America | Baseball Prospectus | MLB.com |
2013 | 50th | X | X |
2014 | 77th | X | 52nd |
X = outside the top-100 overall
He was the 41st overall selection out of high school in the 2012 Entry Draft.
THE SKILLS
A quick summation follows. McCullers has a dynamic arm that produces copious strikeouts. He also loses control of the strike zone frequently and has a history of health issues. Let’s dig
in.
McCullers has had a lot of injuries and slowdowns through the years. Before we get there, let’s look again at his innings pitched marks. Here are those totals again:
26, 104.2, 97, 157.2 and 89
That’s one season in his professional career of 105 innings. That’s a very small number. Remove his 2012 effort and the last four seasons McCullers has averaged 112.1 innings pitched. Again, that’s a very small number for a pitcher that is routinely being drafted to be a 3rd or 4th starter in a mixed league (for more on that see below).
Let’s talk health.
McCullers began last season on the shelf as he dealt with shoulder issues. That cleared up, and then he had elbow issues which caused him to have to shut things down in early August. Don’t know about you, but when a guy has shoulder AND elbow issues... that’s a huge concern for me. He’s apparently healthy now according to agent Scott Boras. "There's nothing from the doctors that we've heard that would suggest that there's going to be any problem for '17," Boras said. Not much in his history suggests we should have such a rosie outlook when it comes to McCullers health.
In an effort to stay healthy, McCullers has tweaked his mechanics to help lessen the strain on his arm. He’s trying to make his motion a bit more compact to keep everything aligned better. McCullers says he’s trying to stay “more even with my body, not letting my arm float so far behind." This sounds like a good idea from a health standpoint, but is it a good thing for his performance outlook? We will have to wait and see on that front.
Lance’s heater is borderline elite, at least in terms of velocity. The average mph of the pitch is 94.1 mph according to PITCHf/x data. He throws the pitch just about 50 percent of the time in his young career. Through two seasons of heat, the results have been extremely poor. On the 1,701 four-seam fastballs he’s thrown batters have crushed the pitch to the tune of a .329/.441/.508 line. Batters have treated the pitch like it was thrown by a 49 year old coach in batting practice.
His curveball is pretty epic and is a much better pitch than his heater. He threw the curveball 35.7 percent of the time as a rookie before jacking that rate up to 49.6 percent last season. Amongst pitchers who threw 100-innings last season, no one in baseball threw their curve more than Rich Hill at 49.7 percent with the next arm in line being Drew Pomeranz at 39.2 percent. Obviously, McCullers curveball use last season was off the charts high. Batters had no chance against his knuckle-curve as it induced some of the weakest production in baseball of any pitch last season (.140/.188/.194 leading to a .173 WOBA). For his 206.2 innings McCullers has limited batters to a .182 wOBA on the pitch.
There are some concerns are out there that because he throws his curveball so much with the belief being that the curve puts lots of strain on the elbow. According to surgeon Neal ElAttrache, one of the leading orthopedic doctors in baseball, the curve shouldn’t be an issue. "He said that the way I throw my curveball probably puts the least amount of stress on my arm of all my pitches. Hearing that was nice because Scott was with me and he wanted him to say something else in that," McCullers said.
A two-pitch pitcher, McCullers is working on adding a changeup this spring. "Everything I throw is hard, hard, hard, and I'm trying to get a little 'stop and go' in my game, a little more 'pitchability,' so to speak," he said. "So, I think I'm going to try some new things out." We will see how that goes.
McCullers has thrown 206.2 innings in his career, a level we expect from an ace, so let’s look at his career work through that lens.
McCullers has generated 10.23 strikeouts per nine with a swinging strike rate of 11.1 percent. His K/9 rate in the minors was 10.2. He’s clearly an elite strikeout arm.
McCullers walked a pathetic 5.00 batters per nine in 2016 to push his career mark to 3.83. The league average the last two seasons is 2.88. That means McCullers has walked nearly a full batter more per nine than the league average. Moreover, only six qualifying pitchers in baseball walked 3.83 batters per nine innings. In the minors the number was even worse at 4.47 per nine.
This leads to an ongoing issue for McCullers – strike throwing. McCullers isn’t very good at it. For his career he has a 56.9 percent first strike mark. The last two seasons the league average was 60.6 percent. For his career, he has thrown 43.7 percent of his pitches in the strike zone. The last two seasons the league average was 44.7. He hasn’t even been league average at throwing strikes. Until he consistently harnesses his fastball, and throws more strikes, it won’t matter how dominating his curveball is. Batters can just spit on the curveball early in the count and look for him to make a mistake with the fastball as they never really have to worry about the off-speed pitch until they fall behind in the count.
The increase in his curveball usage last season led to his groundball rate moving from 46.5 percent as a rookie to 57.3 percent last season. All told, he owns an impressive 50.5 percent mark through his 206.2 innings. Of the 16 men who posted a ground ball rate last season of 50 percent only two of them struck out more than 8.75 batters per nine in Francisco Liriano and Noah Syndergaard. The result of all those grounders for McCullers is a 1.81 GB/FB ratio which is a mark that only 11 men outpaced last season. All those grounders have led to a total of 15 homers allowed at an excellent 0.65 rate per nine over two seasons.
PLAYING TIME
He starts as long as he’s healthy. Simple as that.
AVERAGE DRAFT POSITION DATA
As of this writing, here is McCullers' ADP data.
| Overall | Position Rank |
179.8 | 46th | |
166.5 | 38th |
Fantasy Alarm Player Rankings
CONCLUSION
McCullers has a huge arm which has tons of health concerns. He’s an elite strikeout arm who also generates copious grounders, two parts of the trinity of pitching (strikeouts, grounders and no walks). The third part of the trio though, the walk, shows him to be as bad as he is good in the other two categories. There are things to love with McCullers, but there are also huge negatives.
10-Team Mixed: Can play it two ways. You can make him your 5th because you’re worried about his health. You can make him your fourth thinking that there are so many options on waivers in a league this shallow that you can try to hit a homer, and if it fails, so what?
12-Team Mixed: I want him as my fourth here if I can get a stable 5th. If my top-3 have health risks, I would likely avoid McCullers.
15-Team Mixed: Be smart here. Guys like Ervin Santana and Ian Kennedy are boring as all get out, but when you take a shot on a guy like McCullers you would be wise to roster an arm or two that can give you solid innings since it’s likely you will need them.
AL-Only League: It’s about your risk/tolerance here. He’s got the stuff to be a Cy Young contender. He’s got a track record of ill health like Stephen Strasburg. Sometimes he struggles to throw strikes like Francisco Liriano. There’s a huge breadth of potential outcomes with McCullers.
Ray Flowers can be heard Monday/Tuesday and Thursday/Friday, 8 PM EDT, Wednesday 7 PM EDT on SiriusXM Fantasy Sports Radio (Sirius 210, XM 87). You can also hear Ray Sunday nights at 9 PM EDT PM on the channel talking fantasy sports. Follow Ray’s work at Fantasy Alarm and on Twitter (@baseballguys).
Player News
Daulton Varsho picked up three hits, three RBI and a homer in a win over the Angels on Thursday.
Varsho has only played in seven games this year, but they’ve been seven good ones. He’s homered three times already, and his slugging percentage is a remarkable — and entirely unsustainable — .727 over 22 at-bats. Varsho has been a mediocre offensive player in his two seasons with the Blue Jays, but it’s possible at the age of 28 he’s having a breakout campaign. Far from a guarantee, but possible.
Taylor Ward hit a two-run homer in a loss to the Blue Jays on Thursday.
Ward, 31, gave the Angels a 2-0 lead with a two-run homer off Chris Bassitt in the first inning. He’s now gone deep in two of his last three games, and it ‘improves’ his slash to .181/.224/.391. Ward has been one of the most hot/cold players players in the sport over the last few years, so fantasy managers who can afford to make some roster moves may want to look at Ward while the going is good.
Vladimir Guerrero Jr. picked up three hits and scored twice in an 8-5 win over the Angels on Thursday.
Guerrero also drew a walk. It gives the first baseman multiple hits in back-to-back games, and it’s the third time in May that he’s reached that mark. That’s helped raise his average from .268 to .295, and the only thing fantasy managers can be disappointed with is his .432 slugging percentage. That number should continue to climb as the season unfolds, but Vladdy Jr. has had some inconsistent seasons when it comes to power production.
Chad Green picked up his first save of 2025 with a scoreless ninth against the Angels on Thursday.
Green got the save after Jeff Hoffman worked in back-to-back games — and struggled — in the first two contests against the Angels. He struck out two and looked the part while needing just nine pitches to get through the inning. Hoffman should remain the closer, but Green is on his tail if the struggles were to continue.
Chris Bassitt allowed five runs — four earned — while working six-plus innings against the Angels on Thursday while picking up a win.
Bassitt allowed three runs over the first two innings on a pair of homers, but settled down over his next four frames. He came out to work the seventh, but ended up being charged for two more runs after leaving the contest. The 36-year-old veteran has forged a 3.35 ERA and outstanding 49/8 K/BB ratio over the first quarter of the season, but this wasn’t him at his best. He’ll get the Rays next week if the rotation order stays the same for Toronto.
José Soriano allowed three runs over five innings while not factoring in the decision Thursday against the Blue Jays.
Soriano left with a 4-3 lead, but it was erased quickly after his departure. The 26-year-old was not exactly dominant in his outing with eight hits allowed and four free passes, but he did strike out six to help balance things out a smidgen. Soriano takes an even ERA of 4.00 into a scheduled start against the Padres in San Diego on Tuesday. There should be better options for that one.